Nic Clyde, the senior climate and energy campaigner for Greenpeace Australia-Pacific, said that the U.S. and China have not yet reached “the goal of a truly game-changing climate relationship.”

“Today’s climate announcement by the US and China may be spun as a landmark, but in reality the US pledges are just a drop in the ocean.” —Dipti Bhatnagar, Friends of the Earth International

He added, “There is a clear expectation of more ambition from these two economies whose emissions trajectories define the global response to climate change. Today’s announcements should only be the floor and not the ceiling of enhanced actions.”

In response to the announcement, Greenpeace USA senior legislative Representative Kyle Ash said:    

According to professor of history Juan Cole, who runs the influential Informed Comment blog, “It is a sad commentary that this agreement is actually an improvement on previous goals of the two countries. And it is better to have an agreement with firm dates and targets than to have the two carbon monsters take turns hiding behind each other at climate talks. But this agreement isn’t a commitment to reduce carbon emissions on a timescale appropriate to the magnitude of the crisis. It mostly kicks the ball down the road.”

In reaction to the announcement, executive director of 350.org May Boeve said the U.S-China pledges could be welcomed, but only if the public understands the real implications of agreeing to meet the 2°C  target. In a statement, she said:

As the climate action group TckTckTck points out:

Our work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License. Feel free to republish and share widely.